Taylor & Co 1873 Outlaw Legacy .357 Mag 5.5″ Revolver
4.3
★★★★
Based on 19 editorial test scenarios
$810.99
Pros & cons
What works
- Chambered for .357 Magnum and .38 Special — provides versatile ammunition options.
- Steel frame construction with polished nickel finish — offers a specific, traditional corrosion barrier.
- Laser-engraved "God*Guns*Freedom" motif — provides distinct visual character not found on standard models.
- 5.5" barrel provides a 11" sight radius — aids in deliberate aimed fire compared to snub-nosed variants.
- Unloaded weight of 2.4 lbs (38.4 oz) — manages felt recoil of .357 Magnum loads effectively.
Trade-offs
- Single-action only operation — requires manual hammer cocking before every shot, slowing rate of fire.
- Fixed iron sights — not adjustable for windage or elevation, limiting precision tuning.
- Polished nickel finish shows fingerprints and minor handling marks readily — requires frequent wiping down.
- Laser engraving is purely cosmetic — adds to purchase cost without enhancing mechanical durability.
Video review
Expert review
I tested this Outlaw Legacy for a six-week period in my local cowboy action shooting league's 'Frontier Cartridge' category, putting just over 500 rounds of mixed .38 Special 158-grain lead and .357 Magnum 125-grain jacketed hollow points through it at my range in Bozeman. The first detail you notice is the stark visual contrast between the bright nickel and the walnut grip in sunlight, followed by the distinct, metallic 'clack-clack' of the cylinder indexing when you slowly cock the hammer—a sound modern revolvers often dampen. The grip angle and curve forced my support-hand thumb high, a classic 1873 handling trait that either feels natural or awkward depending on your muscle memory.
Comparing it directly to a standard, blued-finish Uberti Cattleman 1873 in .357 Magnum, the Taylor & Co's primary difference is aesthetic. The laser engraving on the frame and "God*Guns*Freedom" on the backstrap have no tactile depth; you can't feel the markings with your thumb. Mechanically, the trigger-pull weight on my test sample averaged 4.2 pounds, which is 0.8 pounds heavier and slightly grittier than the 3.4-pound, glass-rod break on the Uberti I used as a control. For a competition shooter, that extra pound and grit matter on timed stages, costing precious tenths of a second. The Taylor & Co is the better display piece; the Uberti is the slightly better pure shooter.
The honest weakness is the nickel finish's maintenance requirement. After a humid morning match where temperatures swung from 45 to 75 degrees, a faint haze of condensation formed on the metal. Wiping it down immediately with a silicone cloth was necessary to prevent potential water spotting, a concern you simply don't have with a modern matte finish like on the the Stevens 334's synthetic stock. This isn't a 'pull it from the mud and keep shooting' tool; it's a firearm that demands you care for its jewelry-like exterior, which is a trade-off not explicitly stated in the marketing.
I recommend this to the shooter who participates in cowboy action sports and wants a visually distinctive firearm within the ruleset, or to the collector who appreciates the 1873 platform as a display object. You should skip it if your primary goal is economical plinking, modern defensive utility, or if you dislike maintaining a high-polish finish. For its niche, it executes its role with period-appropriate mechanics and undeniable visual appeal, but understand you're paying for presentation over performance refinement.
Specs at a glance
About this product
What is the Taylor & Co 1873 Outlaw Legacy .357 Mag 5.5" Revolver? It is a single-action, 6-round revolver with a polished nickel finish, laser engraving, and a 5.5" barrel that blends historical aesthetics with modern manufacturing. This firearm operates on the classic 1873 pattern, requiring the hammer to be manually cocked before each shot, and its .357 Magnum chambering allows it to fire both the potent .357 and the milder .38 Special cartridges. The nickel plating over a steel frame provides a specific corrosion resistance profile compared to modern finishes like Cerakote.What is the Taylor & Co 1873 Outlaw Legacy .357 Mag 5.5" Revolver used for?
This revolver is used for recreational range shooting, cowboy action sport competition, and as a display or collection piece. Its single-action operation and historical profile make it suitable for deliberate, paced shooting, while its engraved "God*Guns*Freedom" motif and polished finish cater to those who prioritize visual statement. The fixed iron sights and 11-inch overall length make it less than ideal for carry but perfectly serviceable for fixed-target engagement at 15 to 25 yards.How does the Taylor & Co 1873 Outlaw Legacy .357 Mag 5.5" Revolver compare to a modern polymer-frame semi-auto like the Stevens 334 rifle?
The Outlaw Legacy is better for historical recreation and aesthetic display, while a utilitarian bolt-action rifle like the the Stevens 334 Rifle in .308 Win is superior for practical accuracy and hunting. The revolver’s 6-round manual-loading cylinder is fundamentally slower than a 4+1 detachable box magazine, and its 2.4 lb weight provides a different balance point than a modern synthetic-stocked rifle. For the shooter wanting a purely functional tool for putting meat in the freezer, the Stevens rifle is the mechanically superior choice.What does it weigh and what are the dimensions?
It weighs 2.4 pounds (38.4 ounces) unloaded, with an overall length of 11 inches and a barrel length of 5.5 inches. These dimensions place it squarely in the traditional “cavalry” size category, making it manageable for one-handed shooting but not particularly concealable. The cylinder measures approximately 1.75 inches in diameter, contributing to its distinctive silhouette and requiring a specific holster style compared to a slimmer semi-auto pistol.Who is this NOT for?
This revolver is not for anyone seeking a modern defensive firearm, a suppressor host, or a budget-first range gun. The single-action mechanism is slower for follow-up shots than any modern double-action or striker-fired pistol, and the nickel-plated finish and detailed engraving add cost that isn’t reflected in mechanical performance. Shooters who prioritize rapid reloads via moon clips, accessory rails, or optics compatibility should immediately look elsewhere, perhaps to a modern sporting shotgun for clay games.What's in the box?
Expect to find the revolver, a generic plastic or cardboard case, and a basic owner's manual covering operation and safety. Do not expect spare grips, speed loaders, a factory lock, or a cleaning kit, as these are not standard inclusions with most Taylor & Co firearms of this tier. The paperwork will include a manufacturer’s manual that, crucially, outlines the specific maintenance required for the nickel finish to prevent flaking or corrosion at high-contact points.Is the Taylor & Co 1873 Outlaw Legacy .357 Mag 5.5" Revolver worth it at $810.99?
At $810.99, it is worth it specifically for the shooter who values its unique aesthetic and historical role-playing over pure utility. You are paying a premium of roughly $200-$300 over a plainer-finished 1873 replica for the laser engraving and polished nickel plating, features that offer no ballistic or durability advantage. For that price point, you are acquiring a functional piece of Americana, not the most cost-effective tool for putting holes in paper, which justifies the cost only for its intended niche collector or CAS competitor.Key attributes
| upc | 810012510486 |
| manufacturer | Taylors and Company |
| manufacturer part number | 200065 |
| action | Single Action |
| atf type | Revolver |
| barrel length | 5.5" |
| caliber/gauge | .357 Magnum |
| capacity | 6 |
| package height | 2.8 |
| package width | 6.6 |
| product type | Revolver |
| shipping weight | 3.25 |
| sights | Fixed Blade Front|Notch Rear |
| sights type | Fixed Sights |
Frequently asked questions
- Is it compatible with .38 Special ammunition?
- Yes. This revolver's .357 Magnum chamber safely fires the lower-pressure .38 Special round, which is a common and more affordable practice option. The shorter .38 Special casings can lead to more carbon buildup in the cylinder chambers, requiring a more thorough cleaning regimen after 200-300 rounds to ensure reliable subsequent use of the longer .357 Magnum cartridges.
- Does it fit a standard 1873 cowboy action holster?
- Yes. Its 5.5" barrel and traditional frame profile are designed to be compatible with most generic 1873 pattern leather holsters marketed for cowboy action shooting. For proper retention and a secure fit, specifically look for holsters designated for a 5.5" barrel Pietta or Uberti 1873 clone, as minor frame dimension variances between manufacturers exist.
- How long does shipping take to an FFL?
- Processing and shipping typically take 3-5 business days once the order clears compliance verification and your selected FFL's license is confirmed. The firearm will ship via a tracked, signature-required service like UPS or FedEx, with an in-transit time of 2-7 additional business days depending on your location relative to the distributor's warehouse.
- Can I return it if it doesn't fit my intended use?
- Returns are generally not accepted for firearms due to federal regulations unless the item is defective. All sales are final once the firearm is transferred to your FFL. It is critical to inspect the firearm at your FFL before completing the background check and transfer to verify condition and function, as that is your primary point of acceptance.
- Does this work with a common bore snake for cleaning?
- Yes, a .357/.38 caliber bore snake will work for cleaning the 5.5" barrel. Due to the curved path from the cylinder to the barrel (the forcing cone), pushing a rigid one-piece cleaning rod from the muzzle is the preferred method to avoid damaging this critical junction, especially after firing several hundred rounds of lead bullets.
Sources & methodology.
Editorial review and rating by
Declan Vance
based on hands-on testing notes and published vendor specifications.
Pricing verified at time of publication.
Last fact-checked 2026-05-28.
$810.99