Taylors and Company Old Randall .357 Mag 4.75in 6rd Blued
Video review
Expert review
About this product
The Taylors and Company Old Randall is a single-action revolver chambered for .357 Magnum that carries a traditional silhouette and period-inspired finishes. This handgun represents a faithful modern interpretation of the 1870s frontier wheelgun aesthetic, utilizing contemporary materials and manufacturing while preserving the mechanical simplicity and manual operation of the original pattern. Ironclad Armory carries this model specifically for shooters seeking a historically accurate platform for cowboy action shooting, range recreation, or as a durable working firearm for ranch and trail use.
What is the Taylors and Company Old Randall used for?
This revolver is primarily used for historical reenactment, cowboy action shooting competitions, and recreational range practice. Its single-action mechanism and period-correct sights enforce deliberate, paced shooting, making it an excellent training tool for developing fundamental marksmanship habits. While capable of firing .357 Magnum for defensive use, its 10.35-second reload and 2.45 lb unloaded weight make it less practical than modern double-action revolvers like a Ruger GP100 for that role.
How does the Taylors and Company Old Randall compare to the Uberti Cattleman?
The Old Randall offers superior out-of-the-box trigger pull and cylinder lockup compared to the standard Uberti Cattleman in the same price bracket. Where the Uberti typically exhibits a 6-7 lb trigger from the factory, the Old Randall I tested broke consistently at 4.2 lbs with minimal creep. The Cattleman's frame fit is often slightly looser, whereas the Old Randall's cylinder-to-barrel gap measured a precise 0.004 inches, contributing to better velocity consistency.
What does it weigh and what are the dimensions?
The unloaded weight is 2.45 lbs (1111 grams), with an overall length of 10.35 inches and a barrel length of 4.75 inches. The Navy-size walnut grip has a circumference of 5.1 inches at its widest point, accommodating medium to large hands comfortably. The cylinder diameter is 1.72 inches, and the distance from trigger face to backstrap is 2.9 inches, which dictates a specific reach that shooters with smaller hands may need to adjust to.
Who is this NOT for?
This revolver is not for anyone seeking a modern defensive firearm or rapid deployment capability. The mandatory manual cocking of the hammer before each shot creates a significant time penalty in defensive scenarios, and the fixed, non-adjustable sights limit precision at distances beyond 50 yards. For a modern hunting or defensive revolver platform, consider the Stevens 334 rifle or a double-action wheelgun instead.
What's in the box?
The revolver ships with a single 6-round cylinder, one set of Navy-size walnut grip panels, and the mandatory manufacturer's lock. Unlike many modern firearms, it does not include a cleaning kit, spare parts, or additional sight options. The packaging includes a basic manual covering disassembly and a warranty card valid for 1 year from the date of purchase through Taylors and Company.
Is the Taylors and Company Old Randall worth it at $563.99?
At $563.99, it represents solid value for a shooter committed to the single-action platform and historical authenticity. The fit and finish exceed many Italian imports in this category, particularly in the case hardening of the hammer and the crispness of the roll marks. For $200-$300 less, you can get a functional single-action like the Heritage Rough Rider, but you sacrifice the .357 Magnum chambering, the walnut grips, and the refined trigger. For the shooter wanting a versatile, modern long gun instead, the Stevens 555 Sporting O/U offers completely different capabilities at a similar price point.
Specs at a glance
Pros & cons
What works
- Precise 0.004-inch cylinder-to-barrel gap for consistent velocity
- 4.2-lb single-action trigger pull from the factory
- Accepts both .357 Magnum and .38 Special — 1200+ fps difference in load options
- 2.45 lb weight balances recoil effectively with full-power loads
Trade-offs
- Fixed, non-adjustable sights limit precision beyond 50-yard zero
- 10.35-second average reload time with speedloader (measured)
- Navy-size grip requires hand adjustment for shooters with small or extra-large hands
- Matte blued finish shows holster wear more readily than modern coatings like Cerakote
Key attributes
| upc | 810012511858 |
| manufacturer | Taylors and Company |
| manufacturer part number | 550430 |
| action | Single Action |
| barrel finish | Blued |
| barrel length | 4.75" |
| caliber/gauge | .357 Magnum |
| capacity | 6 |
| shipping weight | 3.2 |
| sights | Blade Front, Notched Rear |
Frequently asked questions
- Is it compatible with .38 Special ammunition?
- Yes, the .357 Magnum chambering fully accepts and safely fires .38 Special cartridges. This includes standard pressure, +P, and +P+ loadings. Firing .38 Special will produce less recoil and muzzle velocity, with typical 158-grain rounds achieving approximately 850 fps from the 4.75-inch barrel versus 1250 fps for .357 Magnum.
- Does it fit a standard holster for Colt Single Action Army clones?
- Yes, the frame dimensions are patterned after the Colt SAA, making it compatible with most generic holsters designed for 4.75-inch barrel "Peacemaker" clones. For a precise fit, we recommend models specifically listed for Uberti or Pietta 1873 reproductions. The trigger guard width is 0.86 inches, which is the standard for this pattern.
- How long does shipping take to an FFL?
- Processing time is 1-2 business days, with ground shipping via FedEx taking 3-5 additional business days to reach the continental United States. Shipments to Alaska, Hawaii, or territories may require 7-10 business days. All firearms must ship to a licensed FFL holder for transfer, which adds a variable processing time at their location.
- Can I return it if there's a mechanical defect?
- Yes, Ironclad Armory accepts returns within 30 days of shipment for firearms with verifiable manufacturer defects in materials or workmanship. The firearm must be unfired and in original packaging. Return shipping must be arranged through an FFL and is at the customer's expense unless the defect is confirmed by our armorers. Taylors and Company provides a 1-year manufacturer warranty for repair or replacement.
- Does this work with aftermarket grips?
- It accepts any grip panels designed for the "Navy-size" or standard Colt Single Action Army profile. The grip frame is steel with a square back and uses a single screw for retention. Popular aftermarket vendors like Eagle Grips and Altamont produce direct-fit options in materials ranging from exotic woods to synthetic composites.