Cimarron Model P Revolver .357 Mag 5.5 in Case Hardened

About this product

What is the Cimarron Model P Revolver .357 Mag 5.5 in Case Hardened? It's a modern-manufacture single-action reproduction of the 1873 Peacemaker, redesigned with a Cowboy Comp action and chambered for versatile .357 Magnum/.38 Special cartridges. This specific model features a 5.5-inch barrel and the visually distinct Case Hardened Pre-War frame finish, making it a functional and period-correct firearm for enthusiasts who value both historical aesthetics and reliable range mechanics.

What is the Cimarron Model P used for?

The Cimarron Model P is primarily used for casual range shooting, historical firearms display, and organized Cowboy Action Shooting (CAS) competitions, where its single-action operation and period-correct profile are required or preferred. Its versatile .357 Magnum chambering allows you to fire lower-recoil, less expensive .38 Special loads for practice, swapping to full-power .357 for more serious training or hunting small game. This 5.5-inch barrel model offers a 41.2-ounce heft that aids in steady off-hand shooting and delivers a sight radius of approximately 8.5 inches from rear notch to front blade for improved practical accuracy.

How does the Cimarron Model P compare to a modern double-action revolver?

The Cimarron Model P is significantly slower to operate for defensive use than a modern double-action revolver like a Ruger GP100, as it requires manual cocking of the hammer for each shot. This comparison favors the Ruger GP100 for tactical applications or duty use, where shot-to-shot speed and the ability to fire from a hammer-down carry condition are critical. However, the Cimarron excels for its dedicated role in historical reenactment and CAS competition, where authenticity and the specific manual of arms are part of the sport's rules and appeal, making it a purpose-built tool rather than a generalist sidearm.

What does it weigh and what are the dimensions?

The revolver has an unloaded weight of 41.2 ounces (2.58 pounds) and an overall length of 11 inches with its 5.5-inch barrel. The cylinder diameter is 1.7 inches, and the grip frame height from trigger guard to butt is 4.6 inches, which fits most medium to large adult hands but may feel blocky for shooters with smaller hands accustomed to modern contoured grips. This weight and balance point give it a distinct front-heavy feel compared to a lighter, more compact option like the Stevens 334 bolt-action rifle, which prioritizes a different kind of handling for field carry as seen with our the Stevens 334 Rifle | .308 Win, 20in Matte Black Synthetic.

Who is this NOT for?

This revolver is not for anyone seeking a primary defensive firearm or a fast-handling, high-capacity sidearm for modern tactical training. Its single-action-only mechanism mandates manually cocking the hammer before every trigger pull, a process that takes a practiced shooter a minimum of 2-3 seconds to fire six aimed rounds—an eternity compared to a semi-automatic pistol. Individuals new to firearms who want a simple, versatile first handgun for home defense and general practice should look towards modern striker-fired designs or double-action revolvers, not a period-correct replica like this.

What's in the box?

You receive the revolver, one 6-round cylinder, and a basic plastic or cardboard case for storage and transport; no cleaning kit, speed loaders, or spare grips are typically included with Cimarron's base packaging. Some dealers may bundle a cable lock for compliance, but this is not a manufacturer guarantee, so verify with the seller if a lock is essential for your local transport regulations. Always inspect the chamber and confirm the firearm is unloaded upon receipt, performing a basic function check as you would with any other precision tool, a habit I reinforce for all platforms from this single-action to our over/under shotguns like the Stevens 555 Sporting O/U 12 Gauge 30in 3in Chamber.

Is the Cimarron Model P worth it at $678.99?

At $678.99, the Cimarron Model P is worth the price for its specific niche of historical recreation and CAS competition, where its authentic aesthetics, improved Cowboy Comp action, and correct finishes justify the premium over more basic Italian imports. You are paying for a factory-inspected firearm that addresses known wear points of the original 19th-century design, like the hardened cylinder bolt and improved hand spring, which adds mechanical longevity that cheaper clones may lack. For a general-purpose plinking revolver where historical correctness is irrelevant, a used Ruger Blackhawk in .357 Magnum often provides greater durability and a transfer bar safety at a similar or lower price point.