Cimarron 1911A1 .45 ACP 5-inch Nickel Walnut
Video review
Expert review
About this product
The Cimarron 1911A1 .45 ACP 5-inch Nickel Walnut is a faithful reproduction of the classic military sidearm built on original-spec frames with period-correct markings and modern manufacturing consistency. This pistol delivers the authentic 1911A1 experience with improved reliability through contemporary production methods and materials, maintaining full parts compatibility with Colt-spec components while offering a distinctive nickel finish not found on issue weapons.
What is the Cimarron 1911A1 used for?
This 1911A1 serves primarily as a range pistol and historical collection piece, balancing authentic military aesthetics with reliable semi-automatic function. I recommend it for shooters who value classic ergonomics and visible craftsmanship, though the fixed sights limit practical accuracy beyond 25 yards compared to modern combat pistols. The nickel finish requires more maintenance than Parkerized or blued alternatives to prevent corrosion from sweat and fingerprints.
How does the Cimarron 1911A1 compare to the Springfield Armory Mil-Spec?
The Cimarron offers superior historical authenticity with its Type 1 smooth mainspring housing and correct markings, while the Springfield Mil-Spec provides better out-of-the-box shootability with modern sights and trigger. Springfield's forged frame and slide construction typically offers tighter tolerances for improved accuracy, making it the better choice for practical shooting—but collectors will prefer the Cimarron's period-correct details and distinctive nickel finish unavailable from most manufacturers.
What does it weigh and what are the dimensions?
This pistol weighs 38 ounces unloaded and measures 8.75 inches in overall length with a 5-inch Government-length barrel. The grip circumference measures 5.3 inches around the walnut panels, fitting medium to large hands comfortably while the 1.3-inch width slides smoothly into most 1911 holsters. These dimensions match original 1911A1 specifications precisely, maintaining the classic balance and pointability that made this platform legendary.
Who is this NOT for?
Avoid this pistol if you need modern defensive capabilities or low-maintenance finishes—the fixed sights and nickel plating demand more attention than contemporary alternatives. Competition shooters will prefer the Stevens 334 Rifle for precision work, while those seeking daily carry should consider polymer-framed options with rust-resistant coatings. The historical focus also means no accessory rail for lights or lasers, limiting tactical applications.
What's in the box?
You receive one pistol, one 7-round magazine, and basic documentation—no cleaning tools or additional accessories included. The magazine follows original 1911 design with a dimpled follower and blued finish, functioning reliably but showing wear more quickly than modern stainless alternatives. I recommend purchasing at least two additional quality magazines from Wilson Combat or Chip McCormick for range sessions, as the single included magazine limits practical use.
Is the Cimarron 1911A1 worth it at $828.99?
At this price point, it delivers authentic 1911A1 characteristics unavailable in most modern reproductions, justifying the cost for collectors and historical enthusiasts. The lifetime warranty provides peace of mind over cheaper alternatives like Philippine-made clones, though the finish may require professional refinishing after 5,000 rounds due to wear on high-contact surfaces. For pure shooting performance, the Stevens 555 Sporting shotgun offers better value—but for historical accuracy, this Cimarron stands alone in its price range.
Specs at a glance
Pros & cons
What works
- 38-ounce weight provides classic 1911 balance and recoil management
- 5-inch Government-length barrel maintains original ballistic performance
- Nickel finish offers distinctive appearance unavailable on most military reproductions
- Lifetime warranty covers manufacturing defects beyond typical 1-year policies
Trade-offs
- Fixed sights limit practical accuracy beyond 25 yards compared to modern pistols
- Nickel finish requires thorough cleaning after each range session to prevent corrosion
- Only one 7-round magazine included—add $40-60 for additional quality magazines
- No accessory rail for lights or lasers limits tactical applications
Key attributes
| upc | 844234128594 |
| manufacturer | Cimarron Firearms |
| manufacturer part number | 1911N00 |
| action | Semi-Auto |
| barrel length | 5" |
| caliber/gauge | .45 ACP |
| capacity | 8 |
| color | Silver |
| length | 13 |
| model | 1911A1 |
| number of magazines | 1 |
| sights | Fixed Sights |
| sights type | FIXED |
| state restriction (ca) | NO DIRECT SHIP TO CALIFORNIA |
Frequently asked questions
- Is it compatible with aftermarket 1911 parts?
- Yes, it maintains full compatibility with Colt-specification parts including barrels, springs, and triggers. The frame uses standard 1911 geometry allowing drop-in installation of most components from Wilson Combat or Brownells. Only the nickel finish may require fitting on some tightly-toleranced aftermarket slides.
- Does it fit standard 1911 holsters?
- Absolutely—the 1.3-inch width and 5-inch barrel length match Government model dimensions perfectly. I've tested it in Safariland 6004 and Blade-Tech Eclipse holsters with no fitting required. The nickel finish may show more holster wear than Parkerized finishes over time.
- How long does shipping take to Montana?
- Standard shipping arrives within 5-7 business days through our partnered FFL network. Express options via UPS or FedEx can reduce this to 3 days for an additional $35 fee. All shipments require signature confirmation and FFL acceptance per federal regulations.
- Can I return it if it doesn't cycle properly?
- Yes, within 30 days for manufacturer defects—we'll cover shipping both ways if the issue involves cycling or feeding problems. Most .45 ACP ammunition cycles reliably, but avoid steel-cased or reloaded ammunition during the break-in period of the first 200 rounds.